Critics' Reactions to "The Devil Wears Prada 2" Unveiled

by : Shonda Rhimes

The eagerly awaited continuation of "The Devil Wears Prada" has made its theatrical debut, sparking a diverse array of critical opinions. Arriving two decades after its predecessor, this new installment brings back beloved stars such as Anne Hathaway, Meryl Streep, Emily Blunt, and Stanley Tucci. The narrative once again immerses viewers in the high-stakes world of fashion publishing, exploring the challenges of maintaining relevance in an increasingly digital age. With a current Rotten Tomatoes score of 74%, the film is praised for its returning cast's strong performances and captivating visual style, though some reviewers note a repetition of certain plot elements.

The original "The Devil Wears Prada," released in 2006, was an adaptation of Lauren Weisberger's 2003 novel, which famously drew inspiration from Weisberger's experiences as an assistant to former Vogue editor-in-chief Anna Wintour. The first film featured Anne Hathaway as Andy Sachs, an aspiring journalist who finds herself working for the formidable Miranda Priestly, editor-in-chief of the elite fashion magazine Runway. Her journey involved navigating Miranda's demanding nature while attempting to maintain her personal life. The movie was a commercial success, earning $327 million globally and solidifying its place as a cultural touchstone.

For the 2026 sequel, both Hathaway and Streep reprise their iconic roles. Emily Blunt returns as Emily Charlton, Miranda's other assistant, and Stanley Tucci as Nigel, Runway's art director. Notably absent is Adrian Grenier, who played Andy's boyfriend Nate in the original. New additions to the cast include Justin Theroux, Kenneth Branagh, Simone Ashley, Lucy Liu, Patrick Brammall, Caleb Hearon, Helen J. Shen, Pauline Chalamet, B.J. Novak, and Conrad Ricamora, along with several surprising cameos. The film's plot revolves around Miranda and Andy's efforts to revitalize Runway's standing in the digital media landscape, confronting the decline of print journalism. They seek assistance from Emily, who has since become an executive at a prestigious luxury fashion house. Original director David Frankel and screenwriter Aline Brosh McKenna also returned to helm the project.

Initial reactions from critics have been varied. David Rooney, chief film critic for The Hollywood Reporter, lauded Hathaway's "effortlessly charming" portrayal and commended the ease with which all four main actors re-inhabited their characters. While appreciating the film's lavish aesthetics, Rooney questioned some of the fashion choices for Miranda's character, highlighting a potential discrepancy. He also touched upon early backlash regarding a perceived stereotype of Andy's assistant, Jin Chao, played by Helen J. Shen, but ultimately suggested it might not significantly impact the film's commercial success, describing the movie as "pretty and polished and as featherweight as a fawning magazine puff piece."

David Fear of Rolling Stone viewed the film through the lens of a journalist, humorously calling it a "horror movie" for those in the profession, regardless of its stylish presentation. He argued that despite the glamorous setting, the film underscores the precariousness of integrity and dedication in media. Peter Bradshaw of The Guardian noted the sequel's adherence to the original's structure, featuring familiar beats like Andy's interactions with Nigel and trips to fashion hubs. He characterized it as "good-natured, buoyant entertainment" that wears well. Brian Truitt of USA Today pointed out the film's tendency to recycle plot points from the first installment, making Andy's renewed struggle to impress Miranda feel redundant. However, Truitt praised the rekindled chemistry between Hathaway and Tucci, and particularly highlighted the development of Emily's character, which he felt compensated for weaker elements, such as a forced romantic subplot involving Andy and a new character.

Beth Webb from Empire praised the lead actors' performances, noting Hathaway's "plucky affability" and Blunt's comedic timing and vulnerability. Tucci's portrayal of Nigel also received positive mention, offering moments for his character to shine. Webb emphasized how the film's world, adorned with designer ensembles, continues to showcase the allure that drives the characters' dedication to Runway. She concluded that Streep's Miranda maintains her magnetic elusiveness and power, even if she lacks a truly formidable antagonist in this installment. Justin Chang of The New Yorker commented that "The Devil Wears Prada 2" effectively delivers its message with conviction and a balanced blend of cynicism and hope. He suggested that as industries and their leaders face decline, the film proposes that the most valuable takeaways are the satisfaction of meaningful work and the enduring friendships forged along the way.

The highly anticipated sequel successfully brings back the iconic cast and the glamorous world of high fashion, offering a nostalgic return for fans while also attempting to modernize its themes. The film's strength lies in the familiar chemistry between its lead actors and its visually stunning production, though critics have pointed out some narrative echoes of its predecessor. Despite minor critiques regarding plot originality and character dynamics, the movie generally delivers an entertaining experience, inviting audiences to once again delve into the captivating and often cutthroat universe of Runway magazine, reminding us of the timeless appeal of its characters and their journeys within the ever-evolving media landscape.